Variable |
Number |
Percentage |
Age |
||
15-24 |
20544 |
37.4 |
25-34 |
17334 |
31.6 |
35+ |
17070 |
31.1 |
Level of Education |
||
No Education |
17921 |
32.6 |
Primary |
9387 |
17.1 |
Secondary |
21717 |
39.5 |
Higher |
5923 |
10.8 |
Religion |
||
Catholic |
6184 |
11.3 |
Protestants |
19782 |
36.0 |
Islam |
28444 |
51.8 |
Traditional/ Others |
538 |
1.0 |
Occupation |
||
Not working |
17404 |
31.7 |
Professional/Sales |
18937 |
34.5 |
Agriculture/Services |
11228 |
20.4 |
Manual/ Others |
7379 |
13.4 |
Wealth Index |
||
Poorest |
9713 |
17.7 |
Poorer |
10163 |
18.5 |
Middle |
10558 |
19.2 |
Richer |
11527 |
20.9 |
Richest |
12987 |
23.6 |
Sex of Household Head |
||
Male |
46971 |
85.5 |
Female |
7977 |
14.5 |
Age of Household Head |
||
15-24 |
2641 |
4.8 |
25-34 |
11457 |
20.9 |
35-54 |
27794 |
50.6 |
55+ |
13056 |
23.8 |
Place of residence |
||
Urban |
23517 |
42.8 |
Rural |
31431 |
57.2 |
Gender |
||
Male |
16971 |
29.48 |
Female |
37977 |
70.52 |
Ethnic group |
||
Yoruba |
7758 |
14.1 |
Ibo |
7843 |
14.3 |
Hausa/ Fulani |
18474 |
33.6 |
Others |
20873 |
37.9 |
Exposure to Mass Media |
||
Not Exposed |
20003 |
36.4 |
Low Exposure |
30666 |
55.8 |
High Exposure |
4279 |
7.8 |
Source: Author'computation, 2019
Figure 2: Types of Health Insurance coverage owned by the respondents
(Source: Authors'computation, 2019)
Figure 2 shows the type of health insurance coverage owned by those who reported having health insurance. The most used type of health insurance is the one provided by the respondents' employers with 88%; the lowest types are the mutual/ community insurance and other types with just 1% while those who owned social security are just 2% of the total respondents who reported having health insurance.
Table 2 shows the association between the respondent's characteristics and health insurance coverage. All other variables were found to be significantly associated with ownership of health insurance coverage apart from the sex of the household head. The highest percentage of individuals with no health insurance coverage are the youths (2=145.7, p<0.05). By education, the highest number of people with health insurance are the highly educated ones (2=137.13, p<0.05), for the association between religion, protestants have the highest number of people with health insurance coverage (2=38.26, p<0.05). The higher percentage of those with health insurance coverage by occupation are the professionals/ sales (2=14.80, p<0.05). Also, by household head, the analysis revealed there are more people with health insurance coverage in male-headed households (2=1.18, p<0.05), there are more individuals with health insurance coverage from households where the household head is between the ages 35-54 (2=5.67, p<0.05). In the analysis, it was also found that there are more health insurance holders in rural areas than urban areas (2=6.69, p<0.05). Also, there are more people with health insurance coverage among the other ethnic groups outside the three major ethnic groups of Hausa, Ibo and Yoruba (2=47.42, p<0.05). Finally, the analysis revealed that there are more people with health insurance coverage among those who are not exposed to mass media of any form (2=61.30, p<0.05).
Table 2: Bivariate association between respondent's characteristics and health insurance coverage in Nigeria.
Variables |
Have health insurance (%) |
Age |
|
15-24 |
281 (1.37) |
25-34 |
433 (2.5) |
35+ |
584 (0.52) |
χ2=145.7 df=2 p<0.05 |
|
Level of Education |
|
No Education |
33 (0.18) |
Primary |
62 (0.66) |
Secondary |
462 (2.13) |
Higher |
707 (11.93) |
χ2=2922.50 df=3 p<0.05 |
|
Religion |
|
Catholic |
207 (3.35) |
Protestants |
691 (3.49) |
Islam |
44 (1.27) |
Traditional/ Others |
3 (0.57) |
χ2=296.19 df=3 p<0.05 |
|
Occupation |
|
Not working |
267 (1.54) |
Professional/Sales |
656 (3.46) |
Agriculture/Services |
237 (2.11 |
Manual/ Others |
103 (1.39) |
χ2=187.73 df=3 p<0.05 |
|
Wealth Index |
|
Poorest |
2 (0.02) |
Poorer |
21 (0.20) |
Middle |
97 (0.92) |
Richer |
232 (2.01) |
Richest |
911 (7.02) |
χ2=1804.88 df=4 p<0.05 |
|
Sex of Household Head |
|
Male |
1070 (2.28) |
Female |
193 (2.41) |
χ2=0.55 df=1 p>0.05 |
|
Age of Household Head |
|
15-24 |
36 (1.34) |
25-34 |
257 (2.24) |
35-54 |
787 (2.83) |
55+ |
183 (1.40) |
χ2=92.87 df=3 p>0.05 |
|
Place of residence |
|
Urban |
939 (3.99) |
Rural |
324 (1.03) |
χ2=524.65 df=1 p<0.05 |
|
Ethnic group |
|
Yoruba |
266 (3.42) |
Ibo |
232 (2.96) |
Hausa/ Fulani |
131 (0.71) |
Others |
634 (3.04) |
χ2=317.15 df=3 p<0.05 |
|
Level of exposure to Mass Media |
|
None |
591 (2.96) |
Low exposure |
597 (1.95) |
High exposure |
16 (1.74) |
χ2=61.30 df=2 p<0.05 |
Source: Author's computation, 2019
Table 3: Binary Logistic Regression of the Correlates of Health Insurance Coverage in Nigeria
Model 1 |
Model 2 |
|||
Variables |
OR |
CI |
OR |
CI |
Age |
||||
15-24 |
1.00 |
1.00 |
||
25-34 |
1.13 |
0.91-1.40 |
1.12 |
0.90-1.39 |
35+ |
1.69** |
1.35-2.12 |
1.65** |
1.31-2.07 |
Level of Education |
||||
No Education |
1.00 |
1.00 |
||
Primary |
1.43 |
0.81-2.51 |
1.50 |
0.85-2.63 |
Secondary |
3.50** |
2.12-5.79 |
3.57** |
2.15-5.92 |
Higher |
13.61** |
8.15-22.70 |
12.90** |
7.72-21.56 |
Religion |
||||
Catholic |
1.00 |
1.00 |
||
Protestants |
0.80 |
0.61-1.05 |
0.81 |
0.61-1.07 |
Islam |
1.00 |
0.63-1.60 |
1.03 |
0.65-1.64 |
Trad./ Others |
0.67 |
0.22-2.04 |
0.66 |
0.22-1.99 |
Occupation |
||||
Not working |
1.00 |
1.00 |
||
Professional/Sales |
1.28** |
1.02-1.60 |
1.29 |
1.03-1.61 |
Agriculture/Services |
1.90** |
1.42-2.54 |
1.92** |
1.43-2.58 |
Manual/ Others |
0.87 |
0.63-1.21 |
0.87 |
0.63-1.21 |
Place of residence |
||||
Urban |
1.00 |
1.00 |
||
Rural |
0.92 |
0.67-1.27 |
0.91 |
0.66-1.27 |
Wealth Index |
||||
Poorest |
1.00 |
1.00 |
||
Poorer |
6.02** |
1.48-24.37 |
6.30** |
1.55-25.50 |
Middle |
19.03** |
5.11-70.92 |
20.62** |
5.53-76.87 |
Richer |
33.92** |
8.92-128.94 |
36.81** |
9.66-140.29 |
Richest |
80.97** |
21.31-307.65 |
85.90** |
22.56-327.09 |
Ethnicity |
||||
Yoruba |
1.00 |
1.00 |
||
Ibo |
1.10 |
0.79-1.52 |
1.06 |
0.77-1.48 |
Hausa/ Fulani |
1.24 |
0.81-1.91 |
1.19 |
0.78-1.82 |
Others |
1.99** |
1.42-2.78 |
1.94** |
1.38-2.72 |
Age of Household Head |
||||
15-24 |
1.00 |
1.00 |
||
25-34 |
1.11 |
0.70-1.77 |
1.11 |
0.70-1.77 |
35-54 |
1.24 |
0.79-1.93 |
1.25 |
0.80-1.96 |
55+ |
0.80 |
0.49-1.29 |
0.80 |
0.49-1.29 |
Sex of Household Head |
||||
Male |
1.00 |
1.00 |
||
Female |
0.80** |
0.65-1.00 |
0.81 |
0.65-1.01 |
Level of exposure to Mass Media |
||||
No exposure |
1.00 |
|||
Low exposure |
0.72** |
0.61-0.85 |
||
High exposure |
0.65** |
0.48-0.87 |
** implies significance at p< 0.05 Source: Author's computation, 2019
Table 3 shows the logistic regression of the correlates of health insurance ownership in Nigeria. In the analysis, variables that were found to be associated with the bivariate analysis were included in the multivariate analysis. Two models were presented below, but in the second model, exposure to mass media was included in the analysis. The result revealed that age, level of education, occupation, wealth index, ethnicity, and sex of the head of the household were found to determine the ownership of health insurance coverage in Nigeria significantly. Specifically, the study found a dose relationship between age of individuals and health insurance coverage, as the age increases, the higher the likelihood of being covered by health insurance. Level of education was found to significantly determine ownership of health insurance, The study found that individuals with primary education were found to be more likely to have health insurance coverage compared to those with no education same for those with secondary as they are 3 times more likely (OR=3.57; CI: 2.15-5.92) and those with higher education are 12 times (OR=12.90; CI: 7.72-21.56) more likely to have health insurance compared to those with no education.
Furthermore, the result showed that individuals of the protestant religious group are less likely to have health insurance coverage compared to the Catholics, while individuals who are of Islam are as likely as Catholics, while traditionalists and other religions are likely than Catholics to have health insurance. Rural residents were found to be less likely to have health insurance coverage compared to urban residents. Individuals in professional/sales (OR=1.92; CI: 1.03-1.61) and Agricultural jobs (OR=1.92; CI: 1.43-2.58) were found to be more likely to have health insurance respectively compared to those who are not working while those in manual jobs were less likely to have health insurance coverage. For the wealth index, the analysis revealed that the richer the household an individual comes from, the more likely they are to have health insurance coverage. Compared to the Yoruba ethnic group, the Ibos, Hausas (OR=1.19; CI: 0.78-1.82) and other ethnic groups (OR=1.94; CI: 1.38-2.72) are more likely to have health insurance coverage. It was also revealed that individuals from female-headed households are less likely to have health insurance compared to those from male-headed households (OR=0.81; CI: 0.65-1.01). For the age of household head, it was found that older the household head, the more likely it is for the members of the household to have health insurance but those in households headed by 55+olds are the least likely to have health insurance compared to those in households headed by 15-24 years old (OR=0.80; CI: 0.49-1.29).
Finally, when exposure to mass media messages were included in the second model, the analysis further revealed similar findings as in the first model, and the result revealed a sort of inverse relationship between exposure to mass media message and ownership of health insurance. The more exposed an individual is to mass media, the less likely it is to have health insurance. The same set of variables that were found to be statistically significant in the first model was also found to be statistically significant in the second model.
Discussion
The study has been able to find that the level of health insurance coverage among low and middle-income individuals is very low in Nigeria; this echoes the reports in literature where report has it that health insurance coverage is only high among those in the highest wealth quintile in Nigerian implying that the coverage is low among the middle and low wealth quintile. Possible reasons for his could be that many of these low and middle-income individuals do not work for the government and are not privy to information about contributory health insurance schemes being offered by the government to civil servants and other government employees. Findings of the study in the multivariate analysis revealed that age is associated significantly with health insurance coverage among low and middle-income individuals in Nigeria; this finding is similar to the findings of [18] where it was found that older individuals had increased odds of health insurance coverage. Other studies that have been found to have relationship between age of individual and health insurance coverage are [29, 30, 34]. One of the studies found that there is a positive relationship between age and health insurance ownership among migrants in the study location in Kenya. It was stated specifically that an increase in migrant age by a year increases the probability of using health insurance services. This relationship could be explained by the fact that older individuals are the ones that are mostly employed in the professional and formal sector compared to the younger population in Nigeria; this might make them be more likely to be enrolled in government and employer-financed private health insurance schemes available.
Level of education was also found to be a significant correlate of health insurance coverage among low and middle-income individuals in Nigeria, specifically the higher the level of education, the higher the odds of being covered by health insurance. The findings mirror the findings of [1, 21, 29, 30, 32-34], where most of these studies found a significant association between health insurance coverage and level of education of an individual. In these studies, most of them reported that having secondary or higher education is associated with higher odds of being covered by health insurance. This present study has also found that the occupation of an individual is a significant correlates of health insurance coverage, specifically, it was found that being employed as a professional or in the formal sector is associated with increased odds of having a health insurance coverage, while those in the informal sector are significantly less likely to have health insurance coverage. This result finds support in the findings of several studies reviewed where it was also reported that being employed in the formal sector is associated with increased odds of owning health insurance [12, 16, 21, 27, 28, 33].
Conclusion and Recommendations
In this study, the level and correlates of health insurance coverage among low and middle-income individuals in Nigeria have been investigated using the 2013 Nigerian Demographic and Health Survey data. It was found that the level of health insurance coverage is very low in Nigeria. Socio-economic and demographic correlates of health insurance coverage that have been identified in this study are age, level of education and occupation of individuals.
With the financial disadvantage faced by this group of people, some of the recommendations that can be given based on the findings of this study include; that the government should ensure that health insurance is subsidized for individuals in low and middle-income levels in the country to increase the enrolment among this group of people. Better awareness should also be created among people in low and middle-income class, individuals with low level of education, people in the agricultural and other unskilled types of jobs, as well as younger people to increase the awareness about the advantages of the health insurance scheme. Finally, plans should be put in place to subsidize the premium for the poor in the short term to absorb them into the scheme and in the long term enact laws and policies to make health insurance compulsory due to the obvious benefits of health insurance.
Authors Contribution
AO conceptualized, reviewed literature, analyzed data, and wrote the manuscript.
Competing Interest
None declared.
Funding
None
Acknowledgement
The author wishes to appreciate the Measure DHS for the permission to use the NDHS data for the study.
References:
- Mhere F. Health insurance determinants in Zimbabwe: Case of Gweru Urban. Journal of Applied Business and Economics. 2013;14(2):62-79.
- Obare V, Brolan C, Hill P. Indicators for universal health coverage: can Kenya comply with the proposed post-2015 monitoring recommendations? International Journal of Equity in Health. 2014;13(123).
- Atinga RA, Abiiro GA, Kuganab-Lem RB. (1). Tropical Medicine and Internationl Health. 2015;20(3):312-21.
- Campbell PC, Owoka OM, Odugbemi TO. National health insurance scheme: Are the artisans benefitting in Lagos state, Nigeria? Journal of Clinical Sciences. 2016;13:122-31.
- Sieverding M, Onyango C, Suchman L. Private healthcare provider experiences with social health insurance schemes: Findings from a qualitative study in Ghana and Kenya. PLoS ONE. 2018;13(2):: e0192973.
- Adefolaju T. Repositioning Health Insurance in Nigeria: Prospects and Challenges. International Journal of Health Sciences. 2014;2(2):151-62.
- Ele GN, Ogbonna BO, Ochei UM, Odili VU. Assessment of National Health Insurance Scheme's (NHIS) Effectiveness in a Tertiary Teaching Hospital in Southeast Nigeria. Journal of Advances in Medical and Pharmaceutical Sciences. 2017;13(3):1-9.
- WHO. Global Health Expenditure Database. World Health Organization: Geneva, Switzerland.: 2012.
- Dogo-Mohammad M. Importance of standards in a demand driven Health Insurance System.3rd Annual SQHN Conference: Safety, Standards and Customer Service Lagos, Nigeria: Society for Quality of Health Care in Nigeria2011.
- Onyedibe KI, Goyit MG, Nnadi NE. An evaluation of the national health insurance scheme (NHIS) in Jos, a north-central Nigerian city. Global Advanced Research Journal of Microbiology. 2012;1(1):5-12.
- Onoka CA, Hanson K, Hanefeld J. Towards universal coverage: a policy analysis of the development of the National Health Insurance Scheme in Nigeria. Health Policy and Planning. 2015;30:1105-17.
- Mulenga JN, Bwalya BB, Gebremeskel Y. Demographic and Socio-economic determinants of women's health Insurance coverage in Zambia Epidemiology Biostatistics and Public Health. 2017;14(1):e12094-1-9.
- Odeyemi IA, Nixon J. Assessing equity in health care through the national health insurance schemes of Nigeria and Ghana: a review-based comparative analysis. International Journal for Equity in Health. 2013;12(9):1-18.
- Jia L, Yuan B, Huang F, Lu Y, Garner P, Meng Q. Strategies for expanding health insurance coverage in vulnerable populations. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2014(11).
- Shiyanbade BW, Makinde WA, Olajide SO, Ogunbela GK, Abdulrasaq N. Re-assessing the collaboration ImplementationStrategies and Administration of National Health Insurance Scheme (NHIS) on End-Users in Nigeria. International Journal of Politics and Good Governance. 2017;VIII(8):1-23.
- Kimani JK, Ettarh R, Kyobutungi C, Mberu B, Muindi K. Determinants for participation in a public health Insurance program among residents of urban slums in Nairobi, Kenya: results from a cross- sectional survey. BMC Health Services Research. 2012;12(66).
- Kipaseyia JS. Factors influencing membership uptake ofNational Hospital Insurance Fund among the poor: a pastoralist' perspective: Strathmore University.; 2016.
- Kazungu JS, Barasa EW. Examining levels, distribution and correlates of health Insurance coverage in Kenya. Tropical Medicine and International Health. 2017;22(9):1175-85.
- Kirigia JM, Sambo LG, Nganda B, Mwabu GM, Chatora R, Mwase T. Determinants of health insurance ownership among South African women. BMC Health Services Research 2005;5(17).
- Masengeli NL, Mwaura-Tenambergen W, Mutai J, Simiyu BW. Determinants of Uptake of Health Insurance Cover Among Adult Patients Attending Bungoma County Referral Hospital. International Journal of Health Economics and Policy. 2017;2(4):145-51.
- Kiplagat I, Muriithi M, Kioko U. Determinant of Health Insurance Choice in Kenya. European Scientific Journal. 2013;9(33):452-68.
- Motlagh SN, Gorji HA, Mahdavi G, Ghaderi H. Main determinants of Supplementary Health Insurance Demand: (Case of Iran). Global Journal of Health Science 2015;7(6):285-94.
- Yellaiah J, Ramakrishna G. Socio economic determinants of health insurance in India: the case of Hyderabad city. International Journal of Development and Sustainability. 2012;1(2):111-9.
- Dixon J. Determinants of Health Insurance Enrolment in Ghana's Upper West Region. Electronic Thesis and Dissertation Repository 2057. 2014.
- Dror DM, Hossain SAS, Majumdar A, Koehlmoos TLP, John D, Panda PK. What Factors Affect Voluntary Uptake ofCommunity-Based Health Insurance Schemes in Low- and Middle-Income Countries? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. PLoS ONE. 2016;11(8):e0160479.
- Yamada T, Yamada T, Chen CC, Zeng W. Determinants of health insurance and hospitalization. Cogent Economics & Finance 2014;2(920271).
- Alkenbrack S, Jacobs B, Lindelow M. Achieving universal health coveragethrough voluntary insurance: what can we learn from the experience of Lao PDR? BMC Health Services Research. 2013;13(521).
- Workneh SG, Biks GA, Woreta SA. Community-based health insurance and communities' scheme requirement compliance in Thehuldere district, northeast Ethiopia: cross-sectional community-based study. Clinico Economics and Outcomes Research. 2017;9:353-9.
- Badu E, Agyei-Baffour P, Ofori Acheampong I, Opoku MP, Addai-Donkor K. Households Sociodemographic Profile as Predictors of Health Insurance Uptake and Service Utilization: A Cross-Sectional Study in a Municipality of Ghana. Advances in Public Health. 2018;2018:1-13.
- Orayo JA. Determinants of Health Insurance among the Migrants in Kenya: University of Nairobi; 2014.
- Wilcox-Gok V. Health Insurance Coverage amng the Elderly Department of Economics and Institute for Health, J. Rubin Health Care Policy, and Aging Research, 1990Contract No.: 149.
- Maina JM, Kithuka P, Tororei S. Perceptions and uptake of health insurance for maternal care in rural Kenya: a cross sectional study. Pan Afrian Medical Journal. 2016;23(125).
- Kimani JK, Ettarh R, Warren C, Bellows B. Determinants of health insurance ownership among women in Kenya: evidence from the 2008-09 Kenya demographic and health survey. International Journal of Equity in Health. 2014;13(27).
- Ibok NI. Socio-Economic and Demographic Determinants of Health Insurance Consumption. Canadian Social Science. 2012;8(5):58-64.
- Nandi A, Ashok A, Laxminarayan R. The Socioeconomic and Institutional Determinants of Participation in India's Health Insurance Scheme for the Poor. PLoS ONE. 2013;8(6):e66296.
- Adebayo EF, Ataguba JE, Uthman OA, Okwundu CI, Lamont KT, Wiysonge CS. Factors that affect the uptake of community-based health insurance in low-income and middle-income countries: a systematic protocol. BMJ Open. 2014;4(e004167).
- Nyorera EN, Okibo W. Factors affecting Uptake of National Hospital Insurance Fund among Informal Sector workers A case of Nyatike Sub-County, Kenya. International Journal of Economics, Commerce and Management. 2015;III(3).
- PRB. World Population Datasheet with Special focus on changing Age Structures. In: Bureau PR, editor. 1875 Connecticut Avenue, NW, Suite 520, Washington, D.C. 20009 USA 800-877-98812018.